SO the FIRST thing that jumps out at US is according to the LDS records and ancestry.com Sarah Chase-Hathaway, my ggg gramma was born on the EXACT same day as her 2nd husband. Maybe that is what drew them together???
Some of the descendants don't think she was married 2xs.

IF this is the correct YEAR OF BIRTH what a woman her mother was, still having babies at age 61.

I will have to ASK that the FAMILY goes back to the REPOSITORY and get some FACTS checked
LOOK at the years of the children's births????

Here is another source:
Abbrev: Hathaways of America (book)
Title: Hathaways of America (book)

Abraham II
Abraham's rootsweb TREE
'***************************************************
Source: S-2097513046 Repository: #R-2142878651 Title: Ancestry Family Trees Publication: Online publication - Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com. Original data: Family Tree files submitted by Ancestry members. Note: This information comes from 1 or more individual Ancestry Family Tree files. This source citation points you to a current version of those files. Note: The owners of these tree files may have removed or changed information since this source citation was created. Page: Ancestry Family Tree Data: Text: family TREE

from rootsweb.com family TREES, gives date/place of birth/death and parents. the kimble/ kelly family Kimble/Kelly Family
"ID: I909
Name: Sarah CHASE
Surname: Chase
Given Name: Sarah
Birth: 11 Sep 1685 in Berkley, Bristol, Massachusetts,

Death: 9 Feb 1754 in Morristown, Morris, New Jersey,

Father: William CHASE b: 15 Jun 1621 in Norfolk, England
Mother: Elizabeth HOLDER b: 1624 in Plymouth, Plymouth, Massachusetts,

Marriage: Benjamin HATHAWAY b: 1699 in Taunton, Bristol, Massachusetts

Children:
10) Benjamin HATHAWAY b:19 Jun 1724 in Dighton, New Jersey,

Marriage Captain Abraham HATHAWAY b: 11 Sep 1685 in Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts

Married: 28 Jan 1710 in Dighton, Bristol, Massachusetts

Children:
1)Abel HATHAWAY b: 1708 in Taunton, Bristol, MA.
2)Philip HATHAWAY b: 1708
3)Susanna HATHAWAY b: 16 Jan 1712 in Berkley, Bristol,
4)Jonathan HATHAWAY b: 16 Oct 1714 in Berkley, 5)Simeon HATHAWAY b: 16 Sep 1716 in Dighton, Bristol, MA.
6)Abraham HATHAWAY b: 28 Jan 1718 in Dighton, Bristol,
7)Sarah HATHAWAY b: 13 Sep 1718 in Dighton, Bristol,
8)Shadrach HATHAWAY b: 20 Feb 1719 in Dighton, Bristol,
two BENJAMIN's
9)Benjamin HATHAWAY b: 10 Mar 1723 in Berkley, Bristol, 11)Hannah HATHAWAY b:7 Oct 1726-Dighton, Bristol, Twin
12)Abigail HATHAWAY b: 7 Oct 1726 in Dighton, Bristol, 13)suzanne HATHAWAY b: 1736 in Bristol, Massachusetts

Sources: Name: Ancestry.com
Title: Family Data Collection - Individual Records
Author: Edmund West, comp.
Publication: Online publication - Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2000. --
Page: Ancestry Family Trees Text: see all the rest on ancestry
'***********************************************************
The wife of Capt. Abraham Hathaway B:1685
and the mother to Abraham III B: circa 1700-10

She is buried in the same cemetery as her brother-in-law Benjamin Hathaway