Son of Nancy Martin and John Hartley.

From Descendants of Philip Hartley:
iii. JOSEPH HARTLEY, b. 01 Jan 1864, Jackson Co., OH; d. 13 May 1944, Lucasville, Valley Twp., Scioto Co., OH; m. MALISA CASTLE HICKMAN, 01 Jan 1936.
Notes for JOSEPH HARTLEY:
Joseph Hartley was born 1 Jan 1864 in Jackson County, Oh. His wife Malisa Castle was 70 years old at the time of his death. He died on 13 May 1944 and was 80y-4m-13 days old. He and his wife resided at Rural Route, Lucasville, Scioto County, Oh and had lived in the area for the past seven years. Joseph was buried at Allen Ridge Cemetery. The cause of death was listed as kidney failure. Death certificate number 35728. This information was taken from the death certificate.

Joseph Hartley and Malisa Castle Hickman were married 1 Jan 1936. Joseph was 72 years old and Malisa was 64 years old. Both were illiterate and signed the marriage certificate with a witnessed (X). This was the second marriage for both. They resided at Rural Route #2, Chillicothe, Ross County, Oh.
Malisa's parents were John Scaggs and Lucinda Rigsby. Malisa was born in Johnson County, Ky. Obit: The Republican Herald, Waverly, Ohio 18 May 1944
Joseph Hartley
Funeral services were held Monday at 2 p.m. at the Jerusalem Chapel at Allen Ridge in Pike County in the charge of Rev. George Maple for Joseph Hartley 80, of Lucasville Route 3 who died on Saturday at 3:00 p.m. at his home on Miller's Run of infirmities. Burial was made in the adjoining cemetery under the direction of Davis-Hammerstein Funeral Home, Beaver.
He was preceded in death by his first wife, Samantha.
Mr. Hartley is survived by his wife Malisa; a daughter, Mrs. Della Grow, both of Beaver; a foster son, George Allen of Springfield Route 4; a brother Thomas of Jackson Route 3; two sisters; Mrs. Rosa Wolfe, of Washington, C.H. and Mrs. Janie Chamberlain of Springfield.
More About JOSEPH HARTLEY:
Age: 80y-4m-13days old at the time of death
Burial: 15 May 1944, Allen Ridge Cemetery, Pike Co., OH Cause of Death: Kidney failure
Death Certificate No.: 35728