William S. Barnett


William S. Barnett

Death 14 Sep 1854 (aged 68)
Ohio, USA
Burial Dayton, Montgomery County, Ohio, USA
Plot Section 10, Lot 222
Memorial ID 32518062 View Source
Suggest Edits

William is the son of John Perry and Elizabeth L. Self Barnett.

He married Nancy Kerlin in 1808 in Johnson Co., Johnson, IN. William drowned in the Ohio River in 1854.

His grandparents are Henry J. "Harry" Barnett and Mary Grundy Barnett.

William is the great, great, great grandson of Pocahontas and John Rolfe, hence their descendants are linked to the earliest days of our country.

The story goes:
John and Elizabeth had 9 children: James, William, Spencer, George, Lucy, Thomas, John, Elizabeth Ann and Ambrose Barnett.

His son William married Nancy Kerlin in 1808. William drowned in the Ohio River in 1854. Nancy Kerlin passed away on December 1, 1831 and is buried what is known today as "The Grave in the Middle of the Road".

It has to be one of America's most unusual burial grounds: A grave that singularly divides a county road.

At each end of the grave is a divided highway sign with a cross in the center, indicating a cemetery. One can only wonder if there's another like it anywhere in the country.

Here's the story: Nancy Kerlin was only 14 — soon to be 15 — when she married William Barnett in 1808. Her husband was the great-great-great grandson of Pocahontas and John Rolfe. Nancy and William lived near present-day Amity, a small community south of Franklin which wasn't actually founded until a number of years later in 1855.

When she died in 1831 at age 39, she was buried at what was apparently one of her favorite places — on a small hill overlooking Sugar Creek. In the following years, several others also were buried there and a small cemetery was created.

Like many Indiana counties, Johnson County had innumerable small cemeteries. One researcher has identified 163 in the county with 54 of them lost and nine removed. This biggest move of all came in the 1940s when a large number of graves were moved so Camp Atterbury could be constructed.

Over time a foot path developed through this small cemetery and later a county road was planned through it. Other graves probably were moved, but one of Nancy's sons objected to moving her grave. Since it originally wasn't a problem, her grave was left behind.

The trouble developed still later when the county wanted to widen the road. Now the grave would have to be moved.

So the story goes, her grandson, Daniel Doty, went to the gravesite with his shotgun and, in essence said, "over my dead body." How long he remained there and what was said by whom to whom isn't definitely known.

The upshot, however, was that the county agreed not to move the grave. Instead, they built the road around it. A concrete slab was placed over the grave to protect it and on Aug. 8, 1912, a historical marker was placed at the site as well.

That's how things still stand today.

In almost any writing about unusual places in Indiana, you will see the gravesite of Nancy Kerlin Barnett included. Also, it is easily seen by traveling a short distance north off U.S. 31 in southern Johnson County. (See "If You Go" box for more information.)

Incidentally, the grandson who protected his grandmother's grave was the son of one of Nancy's daughters, also named Nancy, the eighth of her 11 children. The second Nancy was 20 years old, if records are correct, when she married John Doty in Johnson County in 1843. Daniel was the second of her nine children.

The first Nancy's husband, William, died by drowning in the Ohio River 13 years after her death.

If you go:

GETTING THERE: South on Interstate 69 and Interstate 465 around Indianapolis. Here you have two choices. The most direct route is U.S. 31 South but it has many stoplights. Or you can take Interstate 65 South and at Franklin take S.R. 44 west to U.S. 31. Then go east on C.R. 400S 1.3 miles to the grave.

Family Members



In their memory
Plant Memorial Trees


  • Created by: Rebecca Ann
  • Added: 30 Dec 2008
  • Find a Grave Memorial 32518062
  • Find a Grave, database and images ( : accessed ), memorial page for William S. Barnett (27 Sep 1785–14 Sep 1854), Find a Grave Memorial ID 32518062, citing Woodland Cemetery and Arboretum, Dayton, Montgomery County, Ohio, USA ; Maintained by Rebecca Ann (contributor 46893700) .