*** name also spelled Borntrager ...

Isaac J Bontrager, son of John J Borntrager & his 2nd wife Magdalena "Mattie" Miller Borntrager

1st married 1879 Elizabeth Hattery Bontrager

Known Children
Lydia Ellen Bontrager Troyer
John I Bontrager

2nd married Sevilla M Troyer Kauffman Borntrager, daughter of Moses A Kauffman (d 1893) & his wife Maria Mary Troyer Kaufman Troyer. Her mother 2nd married abt 1895 Jeremiah S Troyer (findagrave memorial 178656584)

Daughters of Isaac & Sevilla

***************************************************

1930 Clark Twp, Holmes Co,OH - Borntrager, widow head Isaac J 73 IN (parents b PA,OH) & daughter Elizabeth 16 OH (parents b IN,OH)

1920 Clark Twp, Holmes Co,OH - Bontrager, widow head Isaac J 63 IN (both parents b IN), daughter Annie 20 IN (both parents b IN) & daughter Mary 14 OH (both parents b IN)

1910 Walnut Creek, Holmes Co,OH - Bontrager, head Isaac J 53 IN (both parents b IN & 2nd married 8y), wife Sevilla 30 OH (both parents b OH & married 8y & 5 children, 4 living), daughter Anna 10 IN (parents b IN,OH), daugher Mary Ann 4 OH (parents b IN,OH), daughter Madgelena 2 OH (parents b IN,OH) & infant daughter 0/12 OH (parents b IN,OH)

1900 Middlebury, Elkhart Co,IN - Troyer, head Jerrey 70 OH (both parents b PA & married 5y) & wife Mary 63 OH (parents b PA,OH & married 5y & 10 children, 8 living) &
Kauffman, daughter Savilla 21 OH (both parents b OH) & granddaughter Anna 8/12 IN (parents b PA,OH)

1880 Van Buren Twp, LaGrange Co,IN - Borntrager, head Isaac 23 IN (parents b PA,OH) & wife Elisebeth 16 OH (both parents b OH)

1870 Sugarcreek Twp, Tuscarawas Co,OH - Yoder, head Barbara 49 OH & Hattery, Elizabeth 6 OH

***************************************************

Name: Elizabeth Borntrager
Date: Feb 06, 1896
Age: 31 Yr
Gender: Female
Race: White
Source location: County Health Office, LaGrange

***************************************************

Name: Isaac J Bontrager
Gender: Male
Marriage Date: 04 Aug 1901
Marriage Place: Elkhart, Indiana
Spouse: Sevilla M Kauffman
FHL Film Number: 1845557

***************************************************

Name: Isaac Bontrager
Gender: Male
Race: White
Age: 81
Marital status: Widowed
Birth Date: 26 Sep 1856
Birth Place: Ind
Death Date: 15 Jan 1938
Death Place: Shipshewana, LaGrange, Indiana
Burial: Bontrager
Father: Isaac
Mother: Mattie Miller