Begin New Search
Refine Last Search
Cemetery Lookup
Add Burial Records
Help with Find A Grave

Find all Phinneys in:
 • Old Burying Ground
 • Gardner
 • Worcester County
 • Massachusetts
 • Find A Grave

Top Contributors
Success Stories
Community Forums
Find A Grave Store

Log In
Sarah Kneeland Phinney
Birth: Mar. 19, 1779
Worcester County
Massachusetts, USA
Death: Mar. 7, 1855
Worcester County
Massachusetts, USA

On Wednesday March 7th, 1855 two aged sisters, Miriam Kneeland (85-born May 1st, 1769), a maiden woman, and her sister, Mrs. Sarah Phinney (75-born March 26th,1779) were found brutally murdered in the home that they shared.

Some unknown party (or parties) entered the home and murdered the two elderly women in their beds with a heavy chair post.

The Murder scene was not discovered until the afternoon of the next day when a neighbor saw cows belonging to the sisters wandering about uncared for. A window found broken was presumed to be the entry point for the intruder.

The news of the crime so shocked Gardner that a $500.00 reward (a small fortune in pre-Civil War New England) was offered for information leading to the conviction of the murderer(s). Legend has it that a Mrs. Shattuck went blind from excessive crying over the untimely passing of her two friends.

The town of Gardner held a collection to purchase a proper gravestone for the beloved sisters. Attendance for the church service for the Kneeland Maids was so great that alternate services at the town hall were held to accomidate the overflow of mourners.

While a man named George Stacey was arrest for the murder a Grand Jury acquitted him. However to this day some still believed him to be the culprit.

Mysteriously, the Kneeland Maid's home burned to the ground a month after the murder. Some whispered that the fire was arson perpetrated by the murderer to destroy evidence...but nothing was ever proven.

To this day the Kneeland Maids Murder remains a topic of debate and speculation. A morbid curiousity about this century and a half old murder still exists in Gardner much in the same manner that many unsolved crimes still fascinate many.

The Kneeland Maids murder has been the subject of multiple newspaper articles, is mentioned in several books on Gardners history and was the subject for historical fiction E-novel "Across Lots" by Carla J Charter.

Even today the Gardner Museum has a display regarding the Kneeland Maids consisting of a wanted poster with a $ 500 reward and a bedside table taken from the crime scene.

The Kneeland Maids grave (ironically) is less then 1/10 a mile from the Gardner Museum and still recieves an ocassional visitor. 
Family links: 
  Timothy Kneeland (1737 - 1818)
  Oliver Kneeland (1764 - 1832)*
  Miriam Kneeland (1769 - 1855)*
  Sarah Kneeland Phinney (1779 - 1855)
  Silas Kneeland (1783 - 1862)*
*Calculated relationship
Old Burying Ground
Worcester County
Massachusetts, USA
Created by: Kyle Brinkmann
Record added: Jan 06, 2005
Find A Grave Memorial# 10281272
Sarah <i>Kneeland</i> Phinney
Added by: Ed Poulin
Sarah <i>Kneeland</i> Phinney
Added by: Ryan-O
Sarah <i>Kneeland</i> Phinney
Added by: Kyle Brinkmann
There are 3 more photos not showing...
Click here to view all images...
Photos may be scaled.
Click on image for full size.

- Lance
 Added: Dec. 20, 2012
I remember you and your Birthday
- Kyle Brinkmann
 Added: Mar. 27, 2012
Remembering you on your Birthday
- Kyle Brinkmann
 Added: Mar. 26, 2010
There are 51 more notes not showing...
Click here to view all notes...
This page is sponsored by: With Love, Colette

Privacy Statement and Terms of Service