Begin New Search
Refine Last Search
Cemetery Lookup
Add Burial Records
Help with Find A Grave

Find all Hortons in:
 • Old Burying Ground of First Presbyterian Church
 • Southold
 • Suffolk County
 • New York
 • Find A Grave

Top Contributors
Success Stories
Community Forums
Find A Grave Store

Log In
Barnabas Horton
Birth: 1600
Harborough District
Leicestershire, England
Death: Jul. 13, 1680
Suffolk County
New York, USA

One of the founders of Southold, Long Island, Puritan community leader Barnabas Horton was born in Mowsley (spelled "Mousely" in some accounts), Leicestershire c.1600, and is said to have brought his gravestone with him to the New World: a 3'x 5' slate slab pre-engraved in England with all but the date of his death. Very little is known of his early life, though he was "probably the son of Joseph Horton", according to the earliest Horton genealogy, which was published in 1876 by descendant George Firman Horton (1806-1886. Barnabas' mother was not unidentified in this genealogy, and remains so to this day for lack of reliable evidence.
Barnabas was twice married while still in England, and fathered two sons by his first wife, Anne Smith, whom he married in 1622: Joseph, born c.1625, and Benjamin. His second marriage, to Mary Langton, produced either seven or eight children. By some accounts he had emigrated to the New World c.1630 in the ship "Swallow", accompanied by Mary and the offspring of his first marriage. After previously living in Massachusetts and Connecticut, he settled in Southold, Long Island at age 38. He died there 42 years later at the age of 80. Described by one local historian as a powerfully-built, ruddy-faced, genial man, he was a baker by trade but possessed of a variety of other skills and talents which led to his success as a settler and community leader. His ledger-style gravestone, which covers a vault interment, had been re-lettered and given a new, more secure foundation during the 1800's by one of his many descendants, and when this historic Southold cemetery was vandalized in January 2004, it was among those which escaped damage. (See gravestone inscription below, which includes Horton's youngest son, Jonathan Horton, the first Captain of Calvary in the County of Suffolk, who was buried at his father's feet. Captain Jonathan Horton died "Feb. 23, AD 1707, Aged 60." BIO BY NIKITA BARLOW

Family links: 
  Joseph Horton (1572 - 1640)
  Anne Smith Horton (1600 - ____)*
  Mary Langdon Horton (1611 - 1670)*
  Mary Horton Budd (____ - 1688)*
  Mercy Horton Youngs*
  Joseph Horton (1625 - 1699)*
  Benjamin Horton (1627 - 1690)*
  Caleb Horton (1642 - 1702)*
  Joshua Horton (1643 - ____)*
  Jonathan Horton (1648 - 1707)*
  Thomas Horton (____ - 1641)*
  Barnabas Horton (1600 - 1680)
*Calculated relationship
"Here sleeps my body tombed in its dust
Till Christ shall come & raise it with the just.
My soul's assended to the throne of God
Where with sweet Jesus now I make aboad.
Then hasten after me my dearest wife
To be pertaker of the blessed life.
And you dear children all follow the Lord.
Hear and obey His publick sacred word
And in your houses call upon His name
For oft I have advised you to the same.
Then God will bless you with your childdren all
And to this blessed place he will you call. HEB. XI; 4: HE BEING DEAD YET SPEAKETH."
*At Horton's feet lie the remains of his youngest son, Jonathan Horton, the first Captain of Calvary in the County of Suffolk. He died Feb. 23, AD 1707, Aged 60.

Note: According to Charlie Stapleton, a Horton descendant, Barnabas Horton's parents were Joseph and Mary Schuyler Horton. Additional info re: marriage date and children from Horton descendant Nancy Buckley Ferguson.
Old Burying Ground of First Presbyterian Church
Suffolk County
New York, USA
Plot: Old Burial Ground Section, Row 6, Stone 015
Created by: Nikita Barlow
Record added: Jan 11, 2004
Find A Grave Memorial# 8265754
Barnabas Horton
Added by: Carrie
Barnabas Horton
Added by: Fred Saar
Barnabas Horton
Added by: Fred Saar
There are 2 more photos not showing...
Click here to view all images...
Photos may be scaled.
Click on image for full size.

~RIP 9th g-Grandfather~
- Crystal♥
 Added: Jul. 13, 2017
My 8th great grandparents
- Doreen
 Added: Jul. 10, 2017
Barnabas Horton - 9th Great-Grandfather.
- Sandra Taylor
 Added: Apr. 2, 2017
There are 60 more notes not showing...
Click here to view all notes...
This page is sponsored by: Pamela Fowler Sweeney

Privacy Statement and Terms of Service