Pioneer Methodist Cemetery

Photo added by Chuck Ellenberger

Pioneer Methodist Cemetery

Also known as Coitsville Methodist Episcopal Cemetery, Home Cemetery

McCartney Road (US 422) and Struthers liberty Road
Campbell, Mahoning County, Ohio, 44505 USA
Memorials 159 added (68% photographed)


Isaac Powers of Youngstown presented a lot of land for a church site and cemetery. The Coitsville Methodist Episcopal Church was erected in 1838. The meeting house was erected atop the knoll above the cemetery. The Church was a victim of arson in 1839. In 1948, a new building was erected upon the same site. (A private dwelling now stands where the church once stood.) The membership merged with the Wilson Avenue Methodist Church in 1919 to form the Marion Heights United Methodist Church located on Woodland Ave. in Campbell.

Restoration of the Coitsville Methodist Episcopal Cemetery was one of the projects of the Campbell Bicentennial Commission. Once restored in 1976, the cemetery was renamed The Pioneer Methodist Cemetery. Miss Emily Redfern, a retired Youngstown school teacher, took it upon herself to protect the history of the cemetery. She established the Pioneer Methodist Cemetery Society. It was through these efforts that funds for the maintenance of the grounds were raised.

The cemetery remains active, although there have been minimal interments in the past 50 years. The city of Campbell now maintains the cemetery.

The cemetery is located in Sharon Township, Mahoning County, Ohio, and is # 7313 (Pioneer Methodist Cemetery / Coitsville Methodist Cemetery / Bethlehem Cemetery) in “Ohio Cemeteries 1803-2003”, compiled by the Ohio Genealogical Society.
The cemetery is registered with the Ohio Division of Real Estate and Professional Licensing (ODRE) as Coitsville M.E. Aka Pioneer Methodist Cemetery with registration license number CGR.0000983390.
The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) Geographic Names Information System (GNIS) feature ID for the cemetery is 1072388 (Pioneer Methodist Cemetery).


This cemetery currently has no photos.

Add Photos


GPS Coordinates: 41.0900150, -80.5778750

  • Added: 1 Jan 2000
  • Find A Grave Cemetery: #42687