Birth year is in question, is it 1835 and not 1838?? I have changed to 1835. Married Henry Joshua Holmes on 20 SEP 1855.

~~~~~~~~

Either dates are wrong or Jemina is not her mother... mother ??
Elizabeth C... b about 1821 TN ?
(Contributor: Jo Ann Hunter Gippner / jograndma)

ARABELLA S. b. 28 May 1835
Married Henry Joshua Holmes
(From Alexander Allison's bio)

Mrs. Jemima Crawford Allison died 13 Oct 1836 when her daughter, Elizabeth J. Allison, was born.
(From Alexander Allison's bio)

It's possible Belle's birth year is off, if not perhaps this is Belle's mother:
Elizabeth Caroline Mathews
BIRTH 30 AUG 1821 • Barren, Kentucky, United States
DEATH 1859 • Jasper, Ralls, Missouri, United States
(From Ancestry)

Arabella Sarah Allison
BIRTH 28 MAY 1835 • Monroe Co., Missouri
Mother as Jemima Crawford
(From bruce_breiner Family Tree on Ancestry)

1850 United States Federal Census
Name: Arabella Alison
Gender: Female
Race: White
Age: 15
Birth Year: abt 1835
Birthplace: Missouri
Home in 1850: District 73, Ralls, Missouri, USA
Attended School: Yes
Household Members Age
William Greathouse 56
Sarah B Greathouse 57
E J Perry 29
Amanda Greathouse 21
Louisa P Greathouse 19
Mary E Greathouse 17
James F M Greathouse 16
Virginia Greathouse 12
Arabella Alison 15

1860 United States Federal Census
Name: Arabella S Homes
[Holmes]
Age: 25
Birth Year: abt 1835
Gender: Female
Race: White
Birth Place: Missouri
Home in 1860: Washington, Monroe, Missouri
Post Office: Somerset
Household Members Age
Henry Homes 26
Arabella S Homes 25
Sarah Homes 4
Amasa Homes 1

1870 United States Federal Census
Name: Arabella Holmes
Age in 1870: 27
Birth Date: abt 1843 ??
Birthplace: Missouri
Home in 1870: Washington, Monroe, Missouri
Race: White
Gender: Female
Post Office: Hunnewell
Occupation: Keeping House
Household Members Age
Henry J Holmes 26
Arabella Holmes 27
Sarah V Holmes 14
Amasa Holmes 11
James H Holmes 4/12