The Presbyterian Cemetery sits behind the Presbyterian Church on the corner at West Main Street and Rochester Street in the center of Lima, Livingston County, New York. This 4 corners is also known as State Routes 5 & 20 and 15 A. You can enter the church parking lot that will get you access to the cemetery by using West Main Street (St. Rt. 5 & 20 ). There is another driveway, around the back of the church that is accessible from Rochester Street (St. Rt. 15 A ) as well.