After the death of her husband Richard Carter, Hannah remarried to a Mr. Enslow in hopes of having a father for her two small children, Mary Trueworthy and Samuel Parker Carter. She bore a child, Franklin Fitzfield to Mr. Enslow on 4 February 1848. On 13 December 1849 she married a Cornelius Brown. Hannah died of small pox, leaving three young children to her sisters. All three were raised under the name of Carter.