Begin New Search
Refine Last Search
Cemetery Lookup
Add Burial Records
Help with Find A Grave

Find all McCarters in:
 • Pumpkin Center Cemetery
 • Tahlequah
 • Cherokee County
 • Oklahoma
 • Find A Grave

Top Contributors
Success Stories
Discussion Forums
Find A Grave Store

Log In
Sponsor This Memorial!
John McCarter
Learn about sponsoring this memorial...
Birth: 1847
Cherokee County
Oklahoma, USA
Death: 1902
Cherokee County
Oklahoma, USA

John McCarter
B:1847 D: 1890/1902
Nancy Crittenden Tobacco McCarter
B: 1880 D: 1880-1890

John McCarter was married to Nancy Crittenden Tobbaco McCarter before 1870. John was the son of Deceiver and DA-YE-NI who preceded him in death. Nancy was the daughter of Jack E. and Sarah McCabe Crittenden. John was listed on the Drennan Indian Rolls in Tahlequah, Oklamoma and was also listed in the 1880 Cherokee Nation Census in Tahlequah, Oklahoma as well as the 1890 Census also in Tahlequah, Oklahoma.

Nancy Crittenden Tobacco McCarter was previously married to John Tobbaco before 1865. Nancy was listed on the 1851 Drennan Rolls at Going Snake and the 1880 Census Cherokee Nation in Tahlequah, 1492 as Nancy McCarty.

Children of Nancy Crittenden Tobacco and John Tobbaco was Susan Ann Tobbaco Tadpole born 1865 and died after 1906.

Children of Nancy Crittenden and John McCarter was:
David McCarter Born 1870 and died before 1902; Archibald McCarter born 1872 and died about 1901; Jock McCarter born 1876 and died before 1902; Mary McCarter Johnson Dirteater was born in 1878 in the Tahlequah District, Cherokee Nation West and died in 1963; Clement McCarter born in 1882 and died after 1906; Peggy or Peggie McCarter Johnson born in 1884 and died after 1906 and also buried in the Johnson Cemetery, Hulbert, Oklahoma.
John and Nancy McCarter and their children are all full-blooded Cherokee belonging to the Cherokee Nation Rolls. Nancy was of the Wolf Clan (NFalling) Their lineage can be traced through the Final Rolls of the Five Civilized Tribes in Indian Territory on Card Number 9327 and 9347 and others.

Nancy Crittenden was listed on the:
1851 Drennan roll: Going Snake, 301
1880 Census (CN): Tahlequah, 1492 as Nancy McCarty

John McCarter was listed on:
1851 Drennan roll: Tahlequah, 5
1880 Census (CN): Tahlequah, 1491
1890 Census (CN): Tahlequah, 3773 
Pumpkin Center Cemetery
Cherokee County
Oklahoma, USA
Plot: not sure tombstones are in Cherokee
Created by: darlene johnson
Record added: Dec 23, 2007
Find A Grave Memorial# 23529390
John McCarter
Added by: darlene johnson
John McCarter
Cemetery Photo
Added by: Donna G
Photos may be scaled.
Click on image for full size.

- Wes T.
 Added: Jun. 4, 2014

Privacy Statement and Terms of Service