Begin New Search
Refine Last Search
Cemetery Lookup
Add Burial Records
Help with Find A Grave

Find all Shirleys in:
 • Greenwood Cemetery
 • Dallas
 • Dallas County
 • Texas
 • Find A Grave

Top Contributors
Success Stories
Discussion Forums
Find A Grave Store

Log In
Sponsor This Memorial!
Elizabeth Pennington Shirley
Learn about removing the ads from this memorial...
Birth: 1816
Jefferson County
Kentucky, USA
Death: Jan. 4, 1894
Dallas County
Texas, USA



"Aunt" Annie Shirley, an Ex-Slave, Gives Her Recollections of the Family History - Riches Vanished With Dream-Like Suddenness.

Mrs. Eliza Pennington Shirley died yesterday at the residence of Mrs. Charlotte T. Poyner, 636 Pacific Avenue, aged 73 years. She was the mother of Myra Maebelle Shirley "Belle Starr", with the facts of whose tragic death in the Indian territory a few years ago the readers of The News are familiar, and she had another daughter, a Mrs. Thompson, who is supposed to be residing in the republic of Mexico. (Elizabeth was born in Louisville, KY to parents unknown, but the Pennington's were close relatives to the Hatfield family which later became famous for their feud with the McCoys. She married John Shirley in Indiana, and immediately they came to Missouri where they settled on a ranch near the community of Medoc (later named Georgia City)about 10 miles from Carthage. Eliza, was an acomplished semstress and she also brought with her to southern Missouri all of the Kentucky graces she had learned as a child. Her social eloquence, and the fact that she was an accomplished pianist, made Eliza the most popular lady around the region.) For several years previous to her death she found herself without means of her own, but the Methodist churches of Dallas came to her relief, kindly paying her board and supplying her every want until death ended her existence. Those churches will also bear the expenses of her interment. Dallas Morning News, January 5, 1894, and in parenthesis taken from the book "The Real Belle Starr" by Phillip W. Steele. 
Family links: 
  John Shirley (1794 - 1876)*
  Belle Starr (1848 - 1889)*
*Calculated relationship
Note: Placed here by Ladies Aid Society as she was a pauper
Greenwood Cemetery
Dallas County
Texas, USA
Plot: Block 4, Lot 35, Space 6
Created by: Connie Baxter Beam
Record added: Nov 05, 2006
Find A Grave Memorial# 16480340
Elizabeth <i>Pennington</i> Shirley
Added by: Sherry
Elizabeth <i>Pennington</i> Shirley
Added by: Jeff Downing
Elizabeth <i>Pennington</i> Shirley
Cemetery Photo
Added by: Momstore
Photos may be scaled.
Click on image for full size.

- Suzie Nash
 Added: Oct. 11, 2014

- Little_Storm
 Added: Feb. 3, 2014

 Added: Aug. 20, 2013
There are 10 more notes not showing...
Click here to view all notes...

Privacy Statement and Terms of Service