Begin New Search
Refine Last Search
Cemetery Lookup
Add Burial Records
Help with Find A Grave

Find all Dunhams in:
 • Higgins Cemetery
 • West
 • Wetzel County
 • West Virginia
 • Find A Grave

Top Contributors
Success Stories
Community Forums
Find A Grave Store

Log In
Malinda Postlethwait Dunham
Birth: Feb. 14, 1879
Wetzel County
West Virginia, USA
Death: Feb. 11, 1933
Wetzel County
West Virginia, USA

Daughter of Joseph Postlethwait and Barbara Cain.

Malinda was a survivor of the Tiffin, Ohio train wreck on January 4, 1887 that took the lives of her father and two brothers, as well as many others.

On that date, in the bitterly cold early morning hours near Republic in Seneca County, Ohio, a Baltimore & Ohio passenger train collided head on with a stalled freight train. The passenger train was traveling approximately 60 mph and the resulting crash caused the passenger cars to accordian into themselves.

The passenger train had two sleepers, a smoking car and 65 people onboard. Joseph Postlethwait had sold his ten acre farm in Wetzel Co., WV and was moving his family to Chillicothe, Missouri to where his brother was living. Joseph had approximately $1,500 in his pocket, which was all of the earthly possessions of his family. His wife, Mary Higgins Postlethwait (the step-mother of his children), their two sons and their daughters were on all the ill-fated train.

Joseph and both of his sons were in the smoking car when the crash occurred. The engineer, who jumped to safety, witnessed the locomotives both rise into the air and then crash into the ground. A fire erupted which killed many of those who survived the initial impact. Joseph and his sons perished in the blaze.

Mary, Joseph's wife, and their daughters who were all in the sleeper cars survived the accident. The family was left penniless as all their money was burned inside Joseph's pockets. Mary was left a widow with 50 cents in her pocket.

Many of the unidentified bodies were taken to the Republic town hall for a mass funeral. After the funeral all were buried in a mass grave. The headstone simply reflects they were victims of the train crash.

Joseph, Spencer and Henry were all taken back to West Virginia for burial.

Malinda's death certificate (#2845) indicates that she is buried here. However, Malinda used different names quite often. When she married Wilford Dunham, a son of George Dunham and Susan Rush, on January 8, 1897 her name was shown as Polly Postlethwait. By 1900, she was shown as "Virtue" in the census records. Her headstone shows the name Virtue Dunham and gives the dates of 1880-1934.

At the age of 53 years, 11 months and 27 days, Malinda died from burns. Insanity was a contributing factor.

------------ೋღ☃ღೋ ------------

A huge THANK YOU to Rhonda Poynter for sponsoring Malinda's memorial! Her kindness and generosity will not soon be forgotten.

------------ೋღ☃ღೋ ------------

Family links: 
  Joseph Postlethwait (1828 - 1887)
  Barbara E Cain Postlethwait (1832 - 1886)
  Wilford D Dunham (1866 - 1945)
  Spencer Postlethwait*
  Sarah A Postlethwait (____ - 1875)*
  Andrew Jackson Postlethwait (1855 - 1905)*
  Leonard Jefferson Postlethwait (1863 - 1919)*
  Henry C Postlethwait (1873 - 1887)*
  Malinda Postlethwait Dunham (1879 - 1933)
*Calculated relationship
Higgins Cemetery
Wetzel County
West Virginia, USA
Created by: kellybean
Record added: Jan 04, 2013
Find A Grave Memorial# 103085363
Malinda <i>Postlethwait</i> Dunham
Added by: Nora Hostutler
Photos may be scaled.
Click on image for full size.

- Big Jake
 Added: Sep. 17, 2016

- Carson
 Added: Aug. 13, 2016

- Diana McDevitt Eyler
 Added: Jul. 15, 2016
There are 226 more notes not showing...
Click here to view all notes...
This page is sponsored by: Rhonda C. Poynter/Gannon/Friends

Privacy Statement and Terms of Service UPDATED