The Plenty Fay Family Cemetery, is the final resting place of Seminole Natives, mixed race Afro/Black-Seminole Natives, and their family/descendants affiliated with the Treaty of Payne's Landing (Second Seminole War). The cemetery began as a small family gravesite on Seminole Nation allotment land, over one hundred years ago. Plenty Fay was a free Black Seminole, who's family had been brought to Indian Territory from Florida. In 1973, the Fay Cemetery Association was formed, and the location would officially be named the "Plenty Fay Family Cemetery." The cemetery is it's own entity under the laws of the state of Oklahoma.
The cemetery hours of operation are from dawn until dusk. There is no loitering, hunting, camping, trespassing, thru traffic, or illegal activity allowed on the property.

In case of incident or emergency on the property, a caretaker may be reached via the Seminole County OK Central Dispatch, at the following non-emergency telephone number: (405)382-9342.

For additional information regarding this cemetery, feel free to email the Fay Cemetery Association at the following:

[email protected].

Related cemeteries are inclusive of the following:

1. Mt. Zion Cemetery (aka-Bruner/Edwards Cemetery)-Little, Seminole County;
2. Scipio Cemetery-Wewoka, Seminole County;
3. Thomas Town Cemetery-Sasakwa, Seminole County;
4. James Cemetery-Murray County, OK;
5. Moppin Cemetery-Konawa, Seminole County, OK;
6. Bruner#1 Cemetery-Bowlegs, Seminole County, OK;
7. Cudjo Cemetery-Seminole County, OK;
8. Westwood Cemetery-Wewoka, Seminole County, OK;
9. Blue Branch Cemetery-Rosedale, McClain County, OK; and
10. Seminole Indian Scout Cemetery-Brackettville, TX.; and
11. Middle Creek Cemetery(Original)-Sasakwa, Seminole County, OK.