Even though it is located on property directly joining New Brashier's Chapel United Methodist Church, the cemetery is not maintained by the church congregation. The cemetery is maintained by the Brashier's Chapel Cemetery Association, Inc. (formerly known as the Brashier's Chapel Cemetery Committee).

Marker transcription:
Brashier's Chapel community was named for Hiram Brashier who emigrated from South Carolina in 1885 and settled near the present day Brashier's Chapel Cemetery. The oldest grave dates to 1866 and is for Mary Tuttle, the maternal grandmother of Stephen Tuttle Thompson, the founder of Arab. In 1891, Mariah C. Brashier sold an acre of land that formally established this site as a community cemetery. Most of the people buried here are linked by blood or marriage and their lives tell the history of this area. Among those buried here are veterans of the Civil War, World Wars I and II, the Koren War and the Vietnam War. Brashier's Chapel Cemetery is recognized as having historical significance in this area and was added to the Alabama Historic Cemetery Register by the Alabama Historical Commission on April 17, 2012.

Listed on the Alabama Historic Cemetery Register
Marker erected in 2013 by Brashier's Chapel Cemetery Committee